Do Australian schools need to ban phones?

July 20, 2019

Some 90 percent of Australian students admit to using devices in class, and research shows kids get better marks in personal-tech-free zones. So should schools ban phones outright?

The French government says yes. It’s prohibited all students under 15 from using smartphones during school hours. Australia may be poised to follow suit.

 

 A British study has shown smartphone bans improve student performance by an average of more than six percent - with the effect  disproportionately strong among low-achieving students. High achievers appeared to do fine with phones or without.

Closer to home, the New South Wales state government has recently launched its own study, under the leadership of acclaimed psychologist Dr. Michael Carr-Gregg.

Dr. Carr-Gregg will review phone bans in France and Albania and release Australian recommendations by the end of 2018.

Do schools have a “Digital Duty of Care”?

Most commentators agree that, for primary-aged children, devices are distracting and, worse, may promote anti-social behaviour.

“That borders on issues around duty of care for young people,” notes Darren Stevenson, educator and chief executive of after-school provider Extend.

Leading digital safety educator Susan (“The Cyber Cop”) McLean, an adviser to the federal government’s Cyber Safety Working Group, agrees. McLean warns further that schools who do nothing risk being sued for failure to provide duty of care.

Citing the tragic suicide of 14-year-old cyberbullying victim Amy “Dolly” Everett earlier this year, McLean adds that schools that interpret their duty of care as an “offline” responsibility need a digital wake-up call.

dollyDolly's suicide: Unspeakable tragedy - and a wake-up call for schools

McLean supports a ban on phones for primary schools - as do many other experts, including University of NSW education professor Dr. Pasi Sahlberg. A “clear ban would be easiest for everyone,” he points out. But educating students about digital balance and wellbeing is essential too.

How would it work for teens?

For older students, an outright ban could backfire, observes Dr. Joanne Orlando, a technology and learning researcher at Western Sydney University.

“When I talk to teenagers about these sort of bans, they normally saying something like ‘well, that just means I have to use my phone in a less obvious way’,” she said.

“It can lead to children being more secretive in their phone use and that means adults and teachers might not be made aware when things go wrong.”

Students need to be taught about safe and balanced technology use, Dr. Orlando insists - not forbidden to use their phones.

Balance starts with limits

But all experts agree that balance requires limits. “Schools need to ask themselves, what are the educational risks and the educational benefits to allowing kids unrestricted access to personal phones?

"The truth is, in most cases, there are no educational benefits. It’s all risks,” says Linewize cyber expert and former undercover internet detective Brett Lee.

Both McLean and Lee cite schools that have successfully implemented no-phone policies - that require students to hand in phones at the start of the school day, and retrieve them at the final bell. But Lee admits that the practice could present logistical and resource challenges for many schools.

Ban - or manage?

“Plus, when we use the word ‘ban’ - it’s too black and white. In an ideal world, school communities would be better off if no child had access to a personal mobile device during the school day.”

In the real world, where many parents (and virtually all students) would object to an outright ban, Lee is a strong advocate for digital management software like Linewize.

“Linewize is the perfect solution for managing kids’ personal devices at school - because it puts the parent in the driver’s seat, no matter where the child happens to be.”

New call-to-action


Topics: Screen time, screens in school, classroom management, digital citizenship, smartphones, digital learning, Duty of Care

Would you like some more information? Or a demo?
Get in touch
Subscribe to our newsletter
Follow us on social media
Popular posts
Cyber Safety | Cyber Experts | screens in school | classroom management | digital citizenship | partner school program
Linewize Classwize: Your superpower for managing student internet
Cyber Safety | Cyber Experts | self-harm | hoax | suicide | momo
The Momo Challenge: What schools need to know
Cyber Safety | Cyber Experts | classroom management | vpn | distraction | BYOD | hotspotting
Six ways students are hacking your firewall
Cyber Safety | Cyber Experts | fights | video recording | school administrator | Social Media
Students filming fights: How should schools respond?
Cyber Safety | grooming | Social Media | dangerous apps
A School's Guide for Managing TikTok

Recent posts

 
What Student Digital Risks Can Your School Expect in 2024?

Helping Australian Schools Better Safeguard Students This Academic Year

 
Navigating harmful content online: A guide to managing children’s exposure to distressing content online

In light of current international events, young people may come into contact with distressing online content. This article has been written ...

 
News about our name

We have some exciting news to share about our name.

 
Safer Internet Day 2023 - Easy ways schools can get involved

Tuesday, 7th February 2023, is Safer Internet Day, an excellent opportunity for your school to educate, inspire and empower your students ...